Episode 365
Ep365: Did the Journal of Discourses Get a Bad Rap?
Did the Journal of Discourses get a bad rap and why? The First Presidency once encouraged Latter-day Saints to buy the Journal of Discourses, and in 1861, George Q. Cannon called it “one of the standard works of the Church.” Today, the LDS Church cites transcription errors and speculative teachings and says the collection on its own carries no doctrinal authority. But is this assessment accurate? On this episode of Mormonish, Unoriginal Jim and Ganesh Cherian join us to make the case that the Journal of Discourses was a highly credible source for early Latter-day Saints and still deserves to be taken seriously as a record of what Church leaders taught. We’ll look at why the Church distanced itself from the volumes as some of those teachings came into conflict with later doctrine. For example, the Journal records Brigham Young calling Adam “our FATHER and our GOD.” But in 1976, Spencer W. Kimball denounced the Adam–God theory as false doctrine. Did the journals fall out a favor as the doctrines fell out of favor and this record became more and more problematic? What does that reversal in how the members are told to regard the Journal of Discourses tell us about how today’s prophets should be heard today? Could a future prophet disavow something members are being taught in general conference today? Could today’s conference talks be tomorrow’s disavowed content?
